"No distinction of God's decrees is more
frequently urged by the Socinians, Remonstrants and others who contend for
the idol of free will, than that of the absolute and conditional. Yet none
is attended with greater absurdities or has fewer claims to acceptance.
The design of the Socinians and their followers on this subject is to
confirm the figment of middle knowledge (scientia media), to establish
election from foreseen faith and to extol the strength of the human will."
The Decrees Of God
|
"We do not deny that various decrees can be called conditional because
they have conditions subordinate to them, although it must be confessed
that it is a less proper way of speaking because the condition ought not
to be confounded with the means; and it is one thing for a thing to be
decreed under a condition, but another for it to be decreed as to be
brought about through such means." The Decrees Of
God
|
"Every decree of God is eternal; therefore it
cannot depend upon a condition which takes place only in time."
The Decrees Of God
|
"God's decrees depend on his good pleasure. Therefore they are not
suspended upon any condition outside of God." The
Decrees Of God
|
"It is absurd for the Creator to depend upon the
creature, God upon man and the will of God (the first cause of all things)
upon the things themselves. But this must be the case if the decrees of
God are suspended on any condition in man."
The Decrees Of God
|
"Conditional decrees cannot be granted without supposing that he who
decreed either was ignorant of the event or that the event was not in the
power of the one decreeing or that he determined nothing certainly or
absolutely concerning the event. All this, being highly derogatory to God,
cannot and ought not to be ascribed to him." The
Decrees Of God
|
"It is one thing to maintain that God has not
decreed to save anyone except through legitimate means; another that the
decree to save these or those persons through legitimate means is
conditional and of uncertain event (which the adversaries feign). Although
faith and perseverance are related as the condition prerequisite to the
decreed salvation (so that without them it ought not to be expected), yet
they hold not the relation of powerful conditions to God's eternal decree
of bestowing salvation upon this or that one in Christ. Indeed so far from
God having decreed salvation to them under such a condition, on the
contrary (by the very same decree by which he decreed salvation to them)
he also decreed faith and perseverance to them and all the other means
necessary for salvation." The Decrees Of
God
|
"It is one thing for the thing decreed to be conditional; another for
the decree itself. The former we grant, but not the latter. There can be
granted an antecedent cause or condition of the thing willed, but not
immediately of the volition itself. Thus God wills salvation to have the
annexed condition of faith and repentance in the execution, but faith and
repentance are not the condition or cause of the act of willing in God,
nor of the decree to save in the intention." The
Decrees Of God
|
"Conditional promises and threatenings do not
favor conditional decrees because they do not pertain to the decreeing
will, but to the preceptive will and are appendages to the divine
commands, added to stimulate and excite men. So he who promises and
threatens under an uncertain condition does not predict or decree what
will actually happen, but only what may happen by the performance or
neglect of the condition. Hence such promises and threats show only the
necessary connection of the condition with the thing conditioned, but
involve no futurition of the thing. Now the decrees have a categorical
verity concerning the thing about to be or not about to be."
The Decrees Of God
|
"The gospel proposition -- to save sinners if they believe -- is
founded upon some decree. Not indeed of the futurition of the thing (as if
it decreed to give salvation to all under the condition of faith), but of
the connection by which God willed indissolubly to join faith with
salvation." The Decrees Of God
|
"I properly infer that all sinners would be
saved if they would believe -- not from any conditional decree, but from
this most certain general truth which God has sanctioned by his absolute
decree (viz., that faith is the infallible means of salvation). For as he
has appointed faith as the only way of bringing men to salvation, hence
arises the truth of this hypothetical proposition -- if a sinner believes
he will be saved (which denotes only the certainty of consequence, but
does not involve the positing of the consequent)."
The Decrees Of God
|
"The various passages of Scripture which speak of future things, this
or that condition being fulfilled (such as Gen. 20:7; 2 S. 17:1-3 with v.
14; 24:13; jet. 16:31 4; 17:24-26; 38:17, 18; 42:9, 10), do not favor any
conditional decrees, but only denote various promises and threats. Indeed
they show the certainty of the connection of one with the other: for
example, of obedience and preservation and salvation, of rebellion and
destruction. But they do not show the futurition of the event either
absolute or conditional or what God has particularly decreed concerning
these or those things. Therefore this is the more true, that since God
(who has all things in his own power) knows that such a condition will
never take place (since he himself has not decreed it), he cannot be said
to have decreed anything under that condition. For nothing can be
conceived more absurd than to maintain that God decrees something under a
condition which at the very moment of decreeing he knows never will take
place." The Decrees Of God
|
"So far is God from changing his decrees to suit
the changes of men, that on the contrary every change of human acts
proceeds from the eternal and irrevocable decree of God (who in this way
brings to pass what he had decreed should take place through promises and
threats). Nor does he change his former opinion by the prayers of the
pious, but by those very prayers accomplishes what he had determined
should come to pass. Thus when God changes what he has made, when he takes
away from man the life he has given, when he destroyed the world he had
created, the change is in the things, not in God. For from eternity, he
decreed to make the change and unless he did so, the decree to make the
change would be changed." The Decrees Of
God
|
"Although the relative properties of God (such as mercy and justice)
suppose for their exercise in the objects about which they are occupied,
some quality (as for instance misery and sin), it does not follow thence
that the decree made concerning the salvation or condemnation of men is
conditional. For although it is supposed in order to its formation, still
it is not suspended on it, but will be most certainly and infallibly
fulfilled according to the good pleasure of God. Whatever is said against
conditional decrees applies equally to the hypothetical will because there
can be no act of will concerning future things out of itself which does
not involve the notion of a decree. Hence they cannot escape who, while
omitting the expression conditional decree, still retain the hypothetical
will; for they mean the same thing, the name only being changed."
The Decrees Of God
|
"Now although we do not deny that the reprobate
(who live in external communion with the church) are called by God through
the gospel; still we do deny that they are called with the intention that
they should be made actual partakers of salvation (which God knew would
never be the case because in his decree he had ordained otherwise
concerning them). Nor ought we on this account to think that God can be
charged with hypocrisy or dissimulation, but that he always acts most
seriously and sincerely." Effectual
Calling
|
"The external call is extended to the reprobate as well as to the
elect; but in a different manner -- to the elect primarily and directly.
For their sake alone the ministry of the gospel was instituted to collect
the church and increase the mystical body of Christ (Eph. 4:12). They
being taken out of the world, preaching would no longer be necessary
because the word of God cannot return unto him void (Is. 55:11). But to
the reprobate, it is extended secondarily and indirectly because, since
they are mingled with the elect (known only to God, 2 Tim. 2:19), the call
cannot be addressed to men indiscriminately without the reprobate as well
as the elect sharing in it (in order that the end ordained by God may be
obtained); as a fisherman in casting his net intends only to catch good
fish, but indirectly closes in his net the bad also mixed with the good."
Effectual Calling
|
"We think that this doctrine [Predestination]
should neither by wholly suppressed from a preposterous modesty, nor
curiously pried into by a rash presumption, but taught soberly and
prudently from the word of God, so that two dangerous rocks may be
avoided, on the one hand of "affected ignorance," which wishes to see
nothing, and blinds itself purposely in things revealed; on the other of
"unwarrantable curiosity," which busies itself to see and understand
everything even in mysteries. They strike upon the first, who, sinning in
defect, think that we should abstain from the proposition of this
doctrine; and upon the latter, who, sinning in excess, wish to make
everything in this mystery scrupulously accurate, and hold that nothing
should be left undiscovered in it. Against both we maintain with the
Orthodox, that Predestination can be taught with profit, provided this is
done soberly from the word of God."
Institutio Theologiae Elencticae, Question 6
|
"Predestination should be taught... Because Christ and the Apostles
frequently taught it... Nor otherwise do Peter, James and John express
themselves, who speak repeatedly of this mystery whenever occasion
offered. Now if it was proper for them to teach, why is it not for us to
learn? Why should God teach what would have been better to be unspoken?
Why did he wish to proclaim those things which it would be better not to
know? Do we wish to be more prudent than God, or to prescribe rules to
Him?" Institutio Theologiae Elencticae, Question
6
|
"Predestination should be taught... because it
is one of the primary Gospel doctrines, and foundations of faith. It
cannot be ignored without great injury to the Church and to believers,
since it is the fount of our gratitude to God, the root of humility, the
foundation and most firm anchor of confidence in all temptations, the
fulcrum of the sweetest consolation, and the most powerful spur to piety
and holiness." Institutio Theologiae
Elencticae, Question 6
|
"The importunity of the Adversaries, who have corrupted this primary
head of faith [Predestination] by deadly errors, and the infamous
calumnies they are accustomed to heap upon our doctrine, impose upon us
the necessity of handling it, so that the truth may be fairly exhibited,
and freed from the most false and iniquitous criminations of evilly
disposed men; as if we introduced a fatal and stoical necessity, as if we
would extinguish by it all religion in the minds of men, and soothe them
on the bed of security and profanity, or hurl them into the abyss of
despair; as if we made God cruel, hypocritical, and the author of sin, I
shudder to relate it. Now as all these things are perfectly false, they
ought unquestionably to be refuted by a sober and healthy exhibition of
this doctrine from the word of God." Institutio
Theologiae Elencticae, Question 6
|
"Although wicked men often abuse this doctrine
imporperly understood; its lawful use towards the pious ought not
therefore to be denied, unless we wish to have more regard for the wicked
than for believers. If, on account of the abuse of some persons we should
abstain from the proposition of this mystery, we must equally abstain from
most of the mysteries of the Christian Religion, which the wicked abuse,
or laugh at or satirize; such as the mystery of the Trinity, the
Incarnation, the Resurrection, and the like."
Institutio Theologiae Elencticae, Question 6
|
"If some abuse this doctrine [Predestination], either to
licentiousness, or to desperation; this happens not per se, from the
doctrine itself, but accidentally, from the vice of men, who most wickedly
wrest it to their own destruction. Indeed, there is no doctrine from which
more powerful incentives to piety can be drawn, and richer streams of
confidence and consolation flow." Institutio
Theologiae Elencticae, Question 6
|
"The Mystery of Predestination is too sublime to
be comprehended by us, as to the why, and he is rash who would attempt to
find out or to assign the reasons and the causes of it; but this does not
hinder it from being taught in Scripture as to the fact, and from being
firmly held by us. Two things, therefore, must be distinguished here, the
one what God has revealed in his Word, the other what He has concealed;
the former we cannot despise unless wickedly, the latter we cannot
investigate unless rashly... To neglect things revealed argues
ingratitude, but to search into things concealed argues pride. We must not
therefore deny what is plain; because we cannot comprehend what is hidden,
as Augustine expresses it." Institutio
Theologiae Elencticae, Question 6
|
"Predestination must be considered not so much a priori, as a
posteriori; not that we may descend from causes to effects, but ascend
from effects to causes; not that we should curiously unroll the book of
life, in order to see if our names are written therein, which is forbidden
to us, but that we should diligently consult the book of conscience, which
we are not only permitted, but also commanded to do, that we may know
whether the seal of God is stamped upon our hearts, and whether the fruits
of election, viz; faith and repentance, may be found in us, which is the
safest way of procceding to the saving knowledge of that doctrine."
Institutio Theologiae Elencticae, Question 6
|